You should speak to your vet before adding peanut butter to your dog’s diet. But even if your dog can eat peanut butter without risk, you still need to be careful… You see, there is an ingredient in some peanut butters that is a severe health hazard. In fact, this ingredient has been responsible for killing thousands of dogs.
Well, it kind of is… Xylitol is a sugar substitute found in many foods, including Peanut Butter and chewing gum – it’s purpose is to give these foods a pleasant sweet taste. Studies have proven that even a small amount of xylitol Can lead to hypoglycemia, liver disease and coagualopathy  Thousands of dogs are poisoned each year by eating food containing xylitol, including peanut butter. To put it simply, feeding your pup xylitol sweetened peanut butter could be a death-sentence. He will happily gulp down peanut butter that contains xylitol – unaware that this could be his last treat ever. That’s why it’s your job to examine the ingredients on your peanut butter carefully. If you see xylitol listed as an ingredient, don’t give it to your dog – save it for your human pals. Fortunately, there are only a few peanut butter brands that use xylitol as an ingredient. That peanut butter sitting in your pantry is probably safe for your dog.
The most popular brands of peanut butter, such as Jif, Skippy, Smuckers and Peter Pan are all xylitol-free. But… Just because your peanut butter is xylitol free doesn’t mean it’s good for your dog . Check the label… You see, many of the peanut butter brands contain sugar, preservatives, and other ingredients that you probably don’t want your dog to eat. Sugar – Refers to sucrose, caramel, corn syrup molasses, and other forms. While sugar may not be immediately harmful to dogs, it can lead to an increased risk of obesity and diabetes. Mono and Diglycerides – While a 2006 Study  found no side effects in the blood work of beagles, Veterinarian, Dr. Sara Ochoa said it’s not an ideal ingredient to feed dogs and may lead to obesity and heart problems. Hydrogenated Vegetable Oils – Refers to a wide range of different oils. Peanut butter is already a high-fat treat without these extra oils. While these ingredients might make the peanut butter more spreadable or keep longer, they do not benefit your dog. If your xylitol-free peanut butter contains one or more of the above ingredients, you might want to swap over to another brand. Beware: “natural” or “organic” peanut butter brands can also contain these unwanted extra ingredients. Take this jar of Natural Jif, for example… Sure, it might be natural, but it contains ingredients like sugar and palm oil that are best avoided. If you are time-poor like me, then crushing your own nuts probably isn’t a realistic option. Fortunately, there are plenty of affordable store-bought brands that are free from unwanted ingredients. I’ll be sharing the best dog-safe peanut butters in just a moment. Whichever peanut butter you buy for your dog, always check the label! The ideal peanut butter for dogs should contain two ingredients at most… As for creamy or crunchy? I personally prefer smooth as I find it easier to spread over my pup’s Kong toy. After reviewing over 50 different peanut butters, we narrowed down our recommendations to just three. These top picks hit the sweet spot between quality ingredients, price, availability and taste. Made from dry-roasted peanuts, this peanut butter contains no extra ingredients. It doesn’t get any more purer than 365 Everyday Value Organic Peanut Butter… It has just one ingredient. Technically, this article was supposed to find the best peanut butter for dogs. But being a peanut butter lover, I couldn’t help myself… I conducted an unofficial taste-test of each peanut butter too!
There is also a crunchy version available, but it does contain salt. Be mindful that 365 Everyday Value makes a wide range of different peanut butters, all of which look very similar. Make sure you check the ingredients if you are grabbing a bottle from your local Wholefood – it’s easy to confuse the jars. The thick consistency made this smooth peanut butter perfect for kong toys and lick mats – it would clump together without dripping onto the floor. It’s easy to see why 365 Everyday Value Organic Peanut Butter was our top pick as the best peanut butter for dogs. For the price, you won’t find a tastier, healthier peanut butter. A chunky organic peanut butter with a satisfying crunch. Perhaps you like you prefer the texture of chunky peanut butter and want to share that crunchy experience with your dog. Not a problem, Teddie Super Chunky Peanut Butter has you covered.
Made in America from USA grown peanuts, this peanut butter is as natural as it is delicious (very!) Best of all, crunchy peanut butter is perfectly safe for dogs to eat. The nuts are crushed small enough that they shouldn’t pose a choking hazard, even in small breeds like chihuahuas.  Just like our previous recommendation, the chunky peanut butter worked well as stuffing inside kong toys and smearing over lick mats. However, I did notice the occasional piece of nut come loose and make its way onto my floor.