The Economic Benefits of Legalizing Weed
Although the Presidential election drew most of the attention in November of 2020, there were several other important decisions made at the polls as well: notably, several states held votes to determine the future of the legal cannabis industry in one form or another. Taking a leaf out of Colorado or Washington’s book, four states—New Jersey, South Dakota, Montana, and Arizona—decided to make marijuana consumption for recreational purposes legal. Mississippi also voted to allow medical marijuana.
All told, more and more states are moving to legalize marijuana (whether for medicinal or recreational use, or both), and the impact has already been tremendous. The legal changes have spawned a burgeoning industry of legal cannabis companies, including those which aim to research and develop cannabis-based medical products, those which are working to distribute and grow marijuana, and many others. All told, more than half of U.S. states have medical marijuana laws on the books, and fifteen states have legalized certain quantities of marijuana for recreational use as well.
The economic benefits of legalizing weed have already been apparent as the first states have moved to change their legal positions. Overall, legal marijuana could mean a big push for state economies and big bucks for both the state and the federal governments. Below, we’ll explore some of the key economic benefits of legal marijuana.
- There has been a growing popular movement in the United States to legalize marijuana for medicinal and recreational uses, with several states adopting such measures already.
- One motivation for legalization is the economic benefits that can come from the regulated commercial availability of marijuana.
- Increased tax revenues, job growth, and investment opportunities all are powerful incentives to push for legalization.
Impact on Tax Revenue
Better than expected sales of marijuana in Colorado and Washington over the past several years have resulted in buoyant tax revenues. In 2019, Colorado collected more than $302 million in taxes and fees on medical and recreational marijuana. Sales in the state totaled over $1.7 billion. Sales in the U.S were $12.2 billion, in 2019, and is projected to increase to $31.1 billion by 2024, according to a report from Arcview Market Research and BDS Analytics. Local research supports this view as well; a report from the Colorado State University-Pueblo’s Institute of Cannabis Research recently found that the legal cannabis industry has contributed more than $80.8 million to the local economy in 2017, primarily through taxes and other fees. Should marijuana become legal on a federal level, the benefits to the economy could be exceptional: a report from cannabis analytics company New Frontier suggests that federally legal pot could generate an additional $105.6 billion in aggregate federal tax revenue by 2025.
That is the carrot that dangled before many states. In December 2019, it was reported that since January 2018, California’s cannabis sales had generated 411.3 million in excise tax, $98.9 million in cultivation tax, and $335.1 million in sales tax. The Massachusetts Cannabis Control Commission reported in November 2019 that in the first year of opening marijuana retailers, $393.7 million was generated in gross sales. (See also: What Will Jeff Sessions Mean for the Marijuana Industry?)
Income and Jobs
Setting up marijuana nurseries and dispensaries would be the first step for the states that voted in favor of medical marijuana. These would not only create jobs but also set the ball rolling for economic activity in the pot industry in these areas. In the case of states like California and Nevada where such infrastructure already exists, the economic impact has become more quantifiable as the sector has matured.
A RCG Economics and Marijuana Policy Group study on Nevada says that legalizing recreational marijuana in the state could support over 41,000 jobs till 2024 and generate over $1.7 billion in labor income. The ICF study estimates at least 81,000 additional direct, indirect and induced jobs in California as a result of legalized marijuana sales. It also projects an increase in total labor income by at least $3.5 billion.
New Frontier’s report predicting the impact of federally legal marijuana suggests that nationwide legalization could generate 1 million jobs by 2025. These jobs would likely come from the quickly growing industry which would spring up across the nation. Workers would be needed to farm, process, distribute, and sell marijuana-based products. Further, there would be ample opportunities for secondary industries which were related to legal cannabis although not directly involved in its production and distribution. These might include software developers, financing services, construction companies, and many others.
Legal marijuana presents the possibility of tremendous benefits to economies on a local and a national scale. It also could help to secure the investment portfolios of investors across the country and further afield as well. While marijuana remains illegal on the federal level, it is difficult for investors to capitalize on the growth of the industry. The number of marijuana-related companies trading on public stock exchanges is miniscule, and while investors do have the option of working with over-the-counter exchanges, many of the most successful businesses in the early legal cannabis space have been based in Canada or other countries.
Should marijuana become legal on the national level, marijuana companies would be free to list their stocks on all U.S. exchanges, thereby enhancing liquidity and opening up access to many more investors. Should the growth rates for the cannabis space continue as they have in recent years, it’s likely that investors would express a keen interest in the industry.
When considering the economic benefits of legal marijuana, it’s important to think of the money that might be saved as well as revenue that could be generated through such a process. Currently, federal marijuana enforcement costs several billion dollars per year. A 2013 report by the American Civil Liberties Union found that the costs at that time were approximately $3.6 billion per year. The more states that legalize cannabis, the lower the cost of enforcement would likely be; if marijuana were to be legalized on a national level, these costs would likely drop considerably. If marijuana were removed from the list of controlled substances, far fewer court cases involving the substance would go to trial, resulting in fewer incarcerations, and, in turn, more money saved.
Legalized marijuana also stands to benefit medical consumers of cannabis-based products. As marijuana becomes legal in more and more parts of the country, it’s likely that the price will drop overall as a result of commoditization. This may not immediately seem like good news for overall tax revenue or for marijuana companies looking to maximize profits. However, individuals utilizing marijuana-based products for medical treatment would stand to benefit considerably from lower prices for these items.
There is ample pushback against the idea of legalizing marijuana across the country. Critics cite the potential for confusion among law enforcement officers aiming to keep up with shifting regulations, a concern about increased homelessness or youth use of the drug, the potential for decreased property values, and much more. Some are opposed to changing the regulatory status of marijuana simply because it means a change to the status quo. All of these reasons combine to decrease the likelihood that marijuana will become legal at a national level any time soon. However, as more and more states move to individually decriminalize pot use in various ways, and as the economic benefits of a legal marijuana industry take effect, there are also many compelling reasons to consider nationwide legalization.As more states vote in favor of legalizing weed, here's a look at the economic benefits to state economies.
How Colorado Spent Its $1 Billion in Weed Money
Want the best of VICE News straight to your inbox? Sign up here.
Colorado has raked in a whopping $1 billion in revenue since it legalized marijuana five years ago.
The state announced Wednesday that it has generated $6.5 billion in sales since it became the first in the nation to legalize the sale of recreational marijuana for adults in 2014. More than $1.5 billion of those sales came in 2018 alone, and 2019 is on track to earn even more.
That money has brought in a ton of tax revenue, which was a major selling point behind legalization in the first place. And it’s gone toward taxpayer-funded housing, education, and safety programs, according to state officials.
“Today’s report continues to show that Colorado’s cannabis industry is thriving, but we can’t rest on our laurels. We can and we must do better in the face of increased national competition,” Gov. Jared Polis, a Democrat, said in a news release. “We want Colorado to be the best state for investment, innovation and development for this growing economic sector.”
Overall, Colorado officials say the state has been left with an extra $1 billion in tax revenue, much of which has been devoted to the Marijuana Tax Cash Fund. Those coffers spend the money on more than 60 programs and grants addressing mental health, education, and more. (Lawmakers get to switch up where the pot cash goes each year and introduce bills to create new programs, according to the Denver Post.)
Of the Marijuana Tax Cash Fund’s budget, 16.4% has gone to education initiatives since retail sales were legalized, according to the state. That’s bankrolled school construction projects, youth literacy, and anti-bullying programs. Lawmakers even set aside $25 million in tax revenue to help school districts in the state set up full-day kindergarten programs, according to the Colorado Sun.
Charter schools can also submit requests for a share of the state marijuana funds, as they’re promised about 12.5% of the overall funding available through the Building Excellent Schools Today (BEST) program.
Overall, the Marijuana Tax Cash Fund budget has contributed to these four areas the most: human services, public health and the environment, education, and local affairs.
All it took was a 2.9% sales tax on medical marijuana, a 15% special sales tax on retail marijuana at the dispensary, and 15% excise tax on retail weed imposed every time it’s transferred from a production facility to a shop.
And that’s all before local taxes, which can add an extra 5% to 10% fee, according to Westword. For example, Aurora has an additional marijuana tax it says funds the Aurora Day Center, which gives homeless people a place to go during the day.
That doesn’t mean that marijuana tax revenue is always a straightforward upside to legalization, though.
For one, high taxes can simply drive low-income drug users to the black market. Plus, an over-reliance on marijuana taxes isn’t necessarily good. California has drastically slashed its expectations for marijuana tax revenue since sales began in 2018, and the state’s black market is still thriving.
More recently, drug policy advocates and even Sens. Kirsten Gillibrand and Cory Booker have said taxes should only benefit the same users who were punished by the U.S.’ history of harsh drug laws and racial inequity.
Cover image: In this Nov. 27, 2015, file photo, a bud tender holds two marijuana buds on his fingers on the way to a customer at the Denver Kush Club in north Denver. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File)
Get a personalized roundup of VICE’s best stories in your inbox.
By signing up to the VICE newsletter you agree to receive electronic communications from VICE that may sometimes include advertisements or sponsored content.Since 2014, the Marijuana Tax Cash Fund has largely gone toward education. ]]>